The impact of COVID-19 on poverty in Kuwait can first be seen through the way in which Kuwait’s economy was substantially affected by the pandemic. Oil exports make up 90% of the country’s GDP, but COVID-19 had a huge impact on oil demand, leading to a large drop in revenue. During the pandemic, oil prices fell to a 17-year low and the oil export revenue fell by half in 2020 as compared to the previous year.
Further, lockdown measures impacted supply chains of goods and services and affected different industries and sectors including “restaurants, retail, tourism and transport.” Lockdowns also impacted businesses, with many SMEs experiencing a large decrease in revenues while suffering increased costs of doing business. Job losses affected employees and consumers experienced higher prices.
Impact of COVID-19 on the Bidoon
Levels of poverty among non-citizens in Kuwait are high, despite the poverty rate in Kuwait being close to zero. Citizens, who make up roughly 30% of the population, have access to “free health care, education and housing,” as well as government employment and extensive subsidies.
Non-citizens, by contrast, often work in the informal sector and do not have access to state services. A specific subset of non-citizens are “Bidoon” meaning “without nationality” in Arabic. Despite having resided in the country before or since its independence in 1961, the government regards them as illegal foreigners and has not granted them nationality, so they are stateless.
The poverty rate among the Bidoon is high. Without nationality, they cannot access the formal job market. In a study, 24% of Bidoon interviewed reported job loss due to COVID-19, with 26% suffering major economic hardship, such as inability to pay rent and medical fees, and limited funds for food. Further, 14% percent reported living in worse living conditions, with landlords evicting 8% from their homes. In terms of humanitarian relief during the pandemic, 61% reported that the government had not considered their needs.
This was due to a requirement to register with one’s civil ID, meaning that government aid was inaccessible to the Bidoon. The impact of COVID-19 on poverty in Kuwait was therefore higher among this community.
Education and Health Care
The pandemic also greatly affected children. Stateless children must attend fee-paying schools, as opposed to state-funded schools and during the pandemic, students were not able to log into the online system to take exams, as they could not provide their identification document number, according to SALAM DHR and ISI report.
Further, according to the same report, stateless people were barred from accessing testing and treatment and hospital entry due to lack of legal status and were excluded from social services. Moreover, stateless people often, despite their conditions, did not seek hospital treatment as they believed that they would be refused treatment. Online registration for the COVID-19 vaccination also proved difficult, due to a lack of an identity number.
The impact of COVID-19 on poverty in Kuwait was therefore wide-ranging among the Bidoon community, affecting a wide range of rights and services.
COVID-19 Impact on Migrant Workers
In March 2020, the state asked all non-essential government workers to stay at home. This particularly affected non-Kuwaitis, the government only employs 4.7% of the expatriate, according to LSE.
Many migrant workers found themselves unemployed, without any means of income and surviving on little food. Further, many were not eligible for the government unemployment insurance scheme. This also affected the families of these workers back home, many of whom depended on the remittances that they received, according to LSE.
Many domestic workers were unable to leave the country and were confined to their employer’s homes due to lockdown restrictions, as a result of the kafala system which ties migrant workers’ visas to their employers. Others lost their employment visas and were at risk of deportation, according to Middle East Institute (MEI).
Further, migrant workers were at increased risk of COVID-19 due to their living conditions. Many work in the construction sector, living in overcrowded, unsanitary camps or dormitories, with little opportunity for social distancing, UNDP reports. Migrant workers were also more vulnerable to COVID-19, with expatriates being twice as likely to need emergency COVID-19 care, according to MEI.
Positive Initiatives During the Pandemic
The en.v Initiative, an NGO “dedicated to building community resilience and civil society capacity” in Kuwait, organized a coordinated response, according to MEI. This has delivered community-level initiatives such as ASWATNA, which empowers youth to shape their education needs.
Its COVID-19 response involved local migrant community organizers, human rights activists, health care professionals, private sector executives and representatives from the International Labor Organization (ILO) and the International Organization for Migration (IOM), MEI reports. The goal was to implement a COVID-19 response, guided by the expertise and experience of local community leaders.
Further, volunteer groups delivered food aid door-to-door to those who had been unable to register. These food packages were tailored to the recipients’ cultural preferences. This initiative also reached non-Arabic and non-English speakers, through registration with community organizers.
According to MEI, other organizations such as Trashtag changed their mission from beach clean-ups, to food delivery. They developed a shared database of recipients, streamlining logistics and ensuring efficient use of funds. They were able to deliver food to around 500 households in three months and observed during the visits the lack of access to clean water. Trashtag then funded the installation of new water filters in houses, to avoid the distribution of environmentally unsustainable water bottles.
The impact of COVID-19 on poverty in Kuwait, therefore, manifested in multiple different ways, having the greatest impact on non-citizens who are more marginalized during normal times, thus driving a disadvantaged proportion of the population into further poverty.
– Ottoline Spearman
Photo: Flickr
6 Facts about the State of Education in Afghanistan
The education system in Afghanistan has faced many obstacles as a result of conflicts and changes in the country’s legal structure. In 2001, only 1 million children attended school in Afghanistan. However, since the Taliban ceased to rule in 2001, according to UNESCO, by 2018, around 10 million children attended school. Despite this improvement, UNICEF statistics indicate that Afghanistan’s out-of-school population equaled 3.7 million children, with girls accounting for 60% of this group. The state of education in Afghanistan has significantly deteriorated since the Taliban takeover in 2021.
6 Facts About the State of Education in Afghanistan
Efforts to Improve Education in Afghanistan
Before the takeover, Afghanistan had significantly progressed in the realm of education. Though gender discrimination continued to impact girls’ education, girls’ school attendance rates did rise — the number of Afghan girls attending primary school rose from nearly zero in 2001 to 2.5 million in 2018.
A six-member project called Step Towards Afghan Girls’ Education Success (STAGES) prioritizes the education of boys and girls in Afghanistan through “community-based education classes in 1,078 communities across 16 provinces.” The project, spanning 6.5 years, began in April 2017 and will run until September 2023. Part one of the project reached completion in June 2021.
By this date, the project had aided the education of almost 25,000 disadvantaged girls in Afghanistan. Part one of the project also helped “1,995 young women to become teachers through a teaching apprenticeship [program] and grants to attend Teacher Training Colleges,” the Girls’ Education Challenge website says. Part two of the project looks to allow community-based education for an additional 5,145 marginalized Afghan girls to finish lower primary education.
By supporting projects like STAGES and mobilizing U.K. and U.S. advocates, the state of education in Afghanistan can improve.
– Safa Ali
Photo: Flickr
Impact of COVID-19 on Poverty in Kuwait
Further, lockdown measures impacted supply chains of goods and services and affected different industries and sectors including “restaurants, retail, tourism and transport.” Lockdowns also impacted businesses, with many SMEs experiencing a large decrease in revenues while suffering increased costs of doing business. Job losses affected employees and consumers experienced higher prices.
Impact of COVID-19 on the Bidoon
Levels of poverty among non-citizens in Kuwait are high, despite the poverty rate in Kuwait being close to zero. Citizens, who make up roughly 30% of the population, have access to “free health care, education and housing,” as well as government employment and extensive subsidies.
Non-citizens, by contrast, often work in the informal sector and do not have access to state services. A specific subset of non-citizens are “Bidoon” meaning “without nationality” in Arabic. Despite having resided in the country before or since its independence in 1961, the government regards them as illegal foreigners and has not granted them nationality, so they are stateless.
The poverty rate among the Bidoon is high. Without nationality, they cannot access the formal job market. In a study, 24% of Bidoon interviewed reported job loss due to COVID-19, with 26% suffering major economic hardship, such as inability to pay rent and medical fees, and limited funds for food. Further, 14% percent reported living in worse living conditions, with landlords evicting 8% from their homes. In terms of humanitarian relief during the pandemic, 61% reported that the government had not considered their needs.
This was due to a requirement to register with one’s civil ID, meaning that government aid was inaccessible to the Bidoon. The impact of COVID-19 on poverty in Kuwait was therefore higher among this community.
Education and Health Care
The pandemic also greatly affected children. Stateless children must attend fee-paying schools, as opposed to state-funded schools and during the pandemic, students were not able to log into the online system to take exams, as they could not provide their identification document number, according to SALAM DHR and ISI report.
Further, according to the same report, stateless people were barred from accessing testing and treatment and hospital entry due to lack of legal status and were excluded from social services. Moreover, stateless people often, despite their conditions, did not seek hospital treatment as they believed that they would be refused treatment. Online registration for the COVID-19 vaccination also proved difficult, due to a lack of an identity number.
The impact of COVID-19 on poverty in Kuwait was therefore wide-ranging among the Bidoon community, affecting a wide range of rights and services.
COVID-19 Impact on Migrant Workers
In March 2020, the state asked all non-essential government workers to stay at home. This particularly affected non-Kuwaitis, the government only employs 4.7% of the expatriate, according to LSE.
Many migrant workers found themselves unemployed, without any means of income and surviving on little food. Further, many were not eligible for the government unemployment insurance scheme. This also affected the families of these workers back home, many of whom depended on the remittances that they received, according to LSE.
Many domestic workers were unable to leave the country and were confined to their employer’s homes due to lockdown restrictions, as a result of the kafala system which ties migrant workers’ visas to their employers. Others lost their employment visas and were at risk of deportation, according to Middle East Institute (MEI).
Further, migrant workers were at increased risk of COVID-19 due to their living conditions. Many work in the construction sector, living in overcrowded, unsanitary camps or dormitories, with little opportunity for social distancing, UNDP reports. Migrant workers were also more vulnerable to COVID-19, with expatriates being twice as likely to need emergency COVID-19 care, according to MEI.
Positive Initiatives During the Pandemic
The en.v Initiative, an NGO “dedicated to building community resilience and civil society capacity” in Kuwait, organized a coordinated response, according to MEI. This has delivered community-level initiatives such as ASWATNA, which empowers youth to shape their education needs.
Its COVID-19 response involved local migrant community organizers, human rights activists, health care professionals, private sector executives and representatives from the International Labor Organization (ILO) and the International Organization for Migration (IOM), MEI reports. The goal was to implement a COVID-19 response, guided by the expertise and experience of local community leaders.
Further, volunteer groups delivered food aid door-to-door to those who had been unable to register. These food packages were tailored to the recipients’ cultural preferences. This initiative also reached non-Arabic and non-English speakers, through registration with community organizers.
According to MEI, other organizations such as Trashtag changed their mission from beach clean-ups, to food delivery. They developed a shared database of recipients, streamlining logistics and ensuring efficient use of funds. They were able to deliver food to around 500 households in three months and observed during the visits the lack of access to clean water. Trashtag then funded the installation of new water filters in houses, to avoid the distribution of environmentally unsustainable water bottles.
The impact of COVID-19 on poverty in Kuwait, therefore, manifested in multiple different ways, having the greatest impact on non-citizens who are more marginalized during normal times, thus driving a disadvantaged proportion of the population into further poverty.
– Ottoline Spearman
Photo: Flickr
AGRI-Ukraine Helps Tackle Global Food Insecurity
The Russian invasion of Ukraine has hindered Ukrainian agricultural production and jeopardized the food supply to the most vulnerable parts of the world. This threatens the food security of millions of people and hinders efforts to tackle global food insecurity.
The Breadbasket of Europe
Ukraine and Russia are the world’s largest suppliers of sunflower products, barley, maize and wheat. Due to its ample agricultural land and vast production of grains, Ukraine is known as the “breadbasket of Europe.”
According to the United Nations, about 821 million people suffered from hunger in 2021. The impact of the Russia-Ukraine war on food prices and the supply of important food supplies has exacerbated hunger, especially among import-dependent developing countries in the Middle East and Africa. For instance, about half of the wheat imports in Tunisia and Lebanon come from Ukraine. Food prices are increasing, and according to the projections of the World Trade Organization, the world should expect further increases if the conflict does not resolve soon.
AGRI-Ukraine: Supporting Ukrainian Farmers
In 2022, the price of wheat increased by about 60%, largely due to the impacts of the Russian invasion, a consequence that significantly affects net food-importing countries. During these times of crisis, support for Ukrainian farmers will help to tackle global food insecurity.
In January 2023, the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) and German multinational biotechnology company Bayer agreed to donate “high-quality vegetable seeds to Ukrainian farmers” to “bolster Ukraine’s export and agricultural sector needs,” the USAID website explains.
Bayer has partnered with USAID’s Agriculture Resilience Initiative for Ukraine (AGRI-Ukraine). This initiative builds on the previously established partnership between AGRI-Ukraine and Bayer, launched in October 2022, to specifically aid Ukrainian farmers and tackle global food insecurity.
Bayer will provide Ukrainian farmers with carrot seeds and USAID will distribute the donation to destitute farmers, with a foremost focus on households in “newly-liberated areas.” The first batch will cover as many as 25,000 homes and smallholder farmers, and over the growing cycle, USAID and Bayer will assess the need for more seeds.
This is a notable example of what can be achieved when the U.S. government and the private sector join forces. These kinds of partnerships have a tremendous positive impact on countries in need of aid.
Bayer for Ukraine
Bayer has supported Ukraine’s agriculture sector for more than 25 years. As part of its participation in AGRI-Ukraine, Bayer is additionally committing more than $35 million to increase the capacity of its Ukraine-based seed processing facility. Furthermore, the German multinational company has contributed “more than 40,000 bags of corn seed” and additional monetary support to secure a “mechanical mine clearing machine” for 1,750 small-scale farmers, enabling them to conduct their farming activities safely with the support of the U.S. Department of State-funded demining activities.
AGRI-Ukraine supports Ukrainian farmers’ access to necessary agricultural commodities, such as fertilizers, seeds and pesticides. Such efforts substantially increase the capacity of Ukrainian businesses to process agricultural goods and export them successfully on the international market.
Restriction in world trade has a snowball effect that impacts the entire global system. An export restriction in one country might provoke export restrictions in other countries, which will cause shortages in goods that states cannot supply themselves. Likewise, the war in Ukraine disrupts food markets, mainly through increasing prices for grains and oilseeds, which has dire ramifications for developing countries in the Middle East and Africa. Bayer’s contribution to AGRI-Ukraine illustrates the benefits of government and private sector collaborations and how joint efforts can help to resolve even the most complex issues.
– Nino Basaria
Photo: Flickr
How Corruption in Developing Countries Impacts Poverty
One of the consequences of corruption is that it can divert resources away from important social initiatives, such as health care and education programs. Moreover, corruption can prevent foreign investment and restrict a nation’s access to international assistance and support.
Addressing Corruption
The United Nations Office on Drugs (UNODC) says addressing corruption in developing countries requires a comprehensive approach that includes strengthening legal and institutional frameworks, promoting transparency and accountability and encouraging citizen participation. Governments can accomplish this by taking steps to strengthen anti-corruption legislation and regulations, increasing accountability in the public sector and giving civil society organizations and the media more authority to observe government operations.
International organizations have created anti-corruption conventions and agreements that encourage countries to combat corruption. For example, the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) seeks to address the key governance issues and provide transparency in the extractive sectors such as oil, gas and mineral resources.
Continued Struggles With Corruption
According to Transparency International’s 2022 Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI), which measures perceptions of corruption in the public sector of 180 countries and territories, many developing nations continue to struggle with corruption. The CPI uses a scale of zero (extremely corrupt) to 100 (extremely clean) to measure this.
“The global average remains unchanged for over a decade at just 43 out of 100” on the CPI scale. Furthermore, 26 nations now have the lowest scores ever noted and more than 66% of nations have received ratings below 50. Across the world, 155 nations have barely progressed in reducing corruption or have seen a deterioration since 2012 despite sustained efforts. The 2022 CPI, therefore, shows that most countries are failing to reduce corruption.
Efforts to Fight Corruption
Civil society organizations and the media play an important role in exposing corruption and holding government officials accountable. Many countries have worked to strengthen civil society and media engagement in anti-corruption efforts.
International aid and support can help countries build the capacity to address corruption by providing technical assistance, training and financial support.
There are many non-governmental organizations (NGOs) that are actively working to combat corruption in developing nations:
Prioritizing Anti-Corruption Efforts
Corruption remains a significant challenge in many developing countries and is a major obstacle to economic growth, social development and good governance. It continues to undermine public trust in government institutions while perpetuating poverty and inequality. Considering the links between poverty and corruption, anti-corruption initiatives designed to address issues of economic growth, income inequality, governance capacity, government services in health care and education and public trust in government are likely to reduce corruption along with poverty.
– Lauryn Defreitas
Photo: Flickr
Advocating for Critical Aid to Ukraine
A local Facebook group “Birmingham Stands With Ukraine” hosted one of Birmingham’s first rallies in support of Ukraine in response to the first strikes of warfare almost a year ago. On February 25, 2023, approximately 50 residents gathered outside Railroad Park in Birmingham, Alabama, to show support for Ukraine amid the ongoing war with Russia and commemorate 365 days of the war in Ukraine. This is the exact spot where many of these same supporters gathered for the first time almost a year ago in support of Ukraine after Russia’s attack on February 24, 2022. With 365 seconds of silence, the group acknowledged the resilience and bravery of the Ukrainian people. The group focuses on organizing local actions such as fundraisers and rallies to aid Ukraine. Since the start of the war in Ukraine, poverty rates have multiplied more than five times, placing more than 8 million Ukrainians in poverty by the close of 2022. These Birmingham residents continue to advocate for critical aid to Ukraine.
Impacts of the Russia-Ukraine War on Global Poverty
Scotty Colson, the Honorary Consul for Ukraine to Alabama, addressed the crowd at the start of the rally and noted how easy it is for the global community to forget about the ongoing war in Ukraine and push the issue out of mind when it does not directly affect them.
People in the U.S. do not see or hear the constant warfare. Some may think that the U.S. has its own problems to worry about. The truth is that the war in Ukraine affects everyone. The Federal Reserve says the war in Ukraine has created a geopolitical risk that has caused a global spike in inflation due to supply chain disruptions and limited access to food and energy resources.
As the war continues, countries all over the world continue to see an overall rise in the cost of living. For example, the exportation of fossil fuels has become so expensive that more households across the world now face the risk of falling into energy poverty. The expense of heating, cooling and lighting has increased to an almost unmanageable level for many households. The World Economic Forum reported in February 2023 that rising costs of living due to the impacts of the Russia-Ukraine war have the potential to push between 78 million and 141 million people below the global poverty line.
Ukraine TrustChain Takes Action
The Ukraine TrustChain is an organization that supports volunteer groups in Ukraine. To provide critical aid to Ukraine, it works hands-on with residents by delivering medicine, food, generators and stoves while repairing war-ravaged schools and homes.
So far, the Ukraine TrustChain has helped more than 1 million Ukrainian residents and tens of thousands of residents continue to receive support weekly. In the most recent March 2023 effort, the Ukraine TrustChain supported a small group by the name of Dobra Spavra that undertakes evacuation missions. The group traveled 16 times in one week into the frontline zones of warfare to evacuate 208 people. The Ukraine TrustChain supplied this group with a van, fuel and vehicle repairs to provide further critical aid to Ukraine through evacuation missions.
The Ukraine TrustChain runs an online art merchandise store to gain financial support for its humanitarian endeavors. It partnered with artists from Ukraine and other supporters around the world to create and sell merchandise such as tote bags, scarves, t-shirts, notebooks and prints of original designs in support of Ukraine. The nonprofit states that 100% of the net proceeds from the sales go to on-the-ground volunteer groups in Ukraine.
Looking Ahead
The rally in Birmingham, Alabama, displays the ability of the average person to contribute to aiding people in war-afflicted countries through advocacy. One person’s Facebook group with 380 current members continues to gain support and raise awareness across the Birmingham area of the need for critical aid to Ukraine. With millions of Ukrainian people living in poverty due to the ongoing war, advocacy and aid efforts are crucial.
– Leah Smith
Photo: Courtesy of Leah Smith
5 Initiatives Helping Children in Mozambique
Mozambique’s multidimensional poverty manifests in low literacy rates with only 63% of adults being literate in 2021. According to USAID, “Among children who finish primary school, nearly two-thirds leave the system without basic reading, writing and math skills.” For this reason, several organizations are centering efforts around helping children in Mozambique meet their basic needs and receive a proper education.
5 Initiatives Helping Children in Mozambique
Looking Ahead
Even though the impacts of poverty on children in Mozambique are harsh, organizations are committed to improving the lives of these children and ensuring a brighter future.
Photo: Flickr
5 Charities Operating in Morocco
5 Charities Operating in Morocco
High Atlas Foundation (HAF) – Founded in the year 2000, High Atlas Foundation reaches social groups around Morocco to help develop, implement and sustain local projects that target economic, social and environmental challenges. The organization has 17 active projects, 400 volunteers and at least 3,000 beneficiaries. Some of the projects include planting trees to empower farming families, empowering women for democratic participation, providing clean drinking water for 1,250 villagers, improving rural Moroccan schools and many more. Since 2011, HAF has had Consultancy Status at the U.N. Economic and Social Council.
Education For All (EFA) – After seeing a 70% illiteracy rate among girls in rural Morocco, EFA stepped in to launch its project in 2007. The aim was to provide high-quality education for girls living close to the High Atlas Mountains in Morocco and with no resources to attend schools in the city. EFA boarding schools serve as “homes away from home” for the admitted girls who get three meals a day, studying supplies and everything else needed for optimal education. With a total of five boarding houses, the number of beneficiaries reached 185 girls in 2017. EFA reports that 90% of all donations it receives go directly into funding the project.
Project SOAR – Established in 2015, Project SOAR’s mission is to empower teenage girls in the rural areas of Morocco and lead them to a better future. So far, the results have been outstanding, as 99.5% of the SOAR girls avoid early marriage or early pregnancy. Also, 100% of SOAR girls go on to pursue higher education compared to only 39% of girls globally. More than 3,700 girls from 42 rural communities across Morocco and Syria have benefited from the program. The girls learn and build social and leadership skills through the program’s activities and workshops. In 2016, Project SOAR started a partnership with Michelle Obama’s “Let Girls Learn” initiative. This led to some beneficiaries and staff visiting the White House for the filming of “We Will Rise” to celebrate the International Day of the Girl.
Though there are several NGOs and charities operating in Morocco, these five stand out for international recognition, and past and present progress. Each is dedicated to tackling several aspects of multidimensional poverty, presenting underprivileged communities with opportunities to grow and learn.
– Sebastián Garcés
Photo: Flickr
The Mayan Train’s Potential Impact on Poverty in Southeastern Mexico
In Mexico, a 900-plus-mile rail project called El Tren Maya (the Mayan Train) brings hope for reduced poverty in the country. The railway, estimated to cost $6.5 billion at the time of the announcement of the project in 2019, will run through five states in Southeastern Mexico and connect everything between Cancún and the Mayan archaeological site at Palenque. Since 2019, the project has been met with both support and concern: while many praise its ability to create jobs, increase tourism and alleviate poverty in Southeastern Mexico, others have questioned its potential impacts on the region’s rural and Indigenous communities.
The Mayan Train Project
President Andrés Manuel López Obrador proposed the Mayan Train project shortly after his inauguration in 2018, stating that it would be “an act of justice” for the country’s poverty-stricken southeastern states. In 2020, the World Bank reported that almost 44% of the country lived under the national poverty line.
Mexico’s poorest states are located in the south of the country. According to the London School of Economics and Political Science, Chiapas, Guerrero and Oaxaca stand as the poorest states — official 2016 poverty data from CONEVAL indicates that about 71% of people across these three states endured poverty, which is significantly higher than the national average of 44%.
López Obrador is not the first Mexican President to take an interest in improving the country’s railroad infrastructure. In 2012, former President Enrique Peña Nieto aimed to construct a railway connecting Cancún to Mérida, but budget cuts halted the project.
Initial funding for the Mayan Train project came from Mexico’s National Fund for the Promotion of Tourism (FONATUR), which issued a €1 billion contract to a consortium of companies in 2021. The project consists of several phases, with plans to both incorporate existing tracks and build new ones. FONATUR has pledged to use federal land for all new construction. In a November 2019 public referendum, 89.9% of the Mexican voters who participated voted in favor of the project.
Project Positives
Those working on the project have estimated that the train will serve 8,000 passengers a day and will attract 3 million people in its initial years of operation. Alstom Transport Mexico, one of the companies involved in the construction, anticipates that the project will immediately generate more than 11,000 jobs and “boost economic growth in the southeast.”
A U.N.-Habitat analysis of the Mayan Train’s larger potential impact concluded that the project would ultimately generate some 945,000 new jobs in the region while enhancing access to education and the labor market. This would help to reduce poverty in Southeastern Mexico and Mexico as a whole, where the unemployment rate stood at 2.9% (more than a million people) in January 2023 and nearly 4 million people lived in poverty in 2020.
Concerns among Indigenous Communities
Despite the project’s projected ability to alleviate unemployment and poverty in Southeastern Mexico, there are some concerns, specifically among Mexico’s Indigenous communities. In 2020, 69.5% of Mexico’s Indigenous population lived in poverty, mainly in the country’s southern states. In 2020, the Mayan communities of Campeche issued a petition, signed by 268,000 people, to the Ministry of Environment and Natural Resources requesting the suspension of the Mayan Train project.
Members of the Regional Indigenous Council of Xpujil stated that the communities did not receive “timely and sufficient information to give their consent” to the construction. Their concerns centered on the environmental impact of the Mayan Train project and its potential threat to the conservation of sacred lands. Indigenous communities have also expressed concern that the project will only benefit tourists and the wealthy.
Looking Ahead
Addressing these concerns, the U.N. estimates that 46% of the nearly 1 million jobs generated by the Mayan Train will benefit Indigenous peoples. FONATUR and U.N.-Habitat have also collaborated to develop a set of urban planning and design guidelines aimed at ensuring environmental responsibility, social inclusion and equitable benefit across the region’s communities.
A sign of progress and hope for Southeastern Mexico, construction of the Mayan Train resumed in late 2022, with plans for the first segment of the railroad to begin operating in December 2023.
– Audrey Gaines
Photo: Flickr
The First Metro Railway in Bangladesh
Despite being one of 46 countries included in the current U.N. List of Least Developed Countries, Bangladesh has experienced strong economic growth in recent years. In 2021, the country’s GDP growth rate stood at 6.9%. The construction of the first metro railway in Bangladesh has the potential to boost the economy, improve quality of life and reduce poverty among the 35 million people who live below the poverty line as of 2022.
Dhaka Metro Rail
Bangladesh’s first metro railway line is undergoing development in the capital city of Dhaka. The government-owned company Dhaka Mass Transit Company Limited (DMTCL) was incorporated in June 2013 to oversee the rail network’s construction. The company aims to “reduce traffic congestion” by establishing a “state-of-the-art public transport system” that is “environment-friendly” and “time-saving.”
The Time-bound Action Plan 2030 that the Government of Bangladesh formulated outlines that six Mass Rapid Transit train routes spanning 128.741 kilometers across Dhaka and its adjoining neighborhoods will undergo construction by 2030. The first phase of Line 6 has already reached completion and opened in December 2022, carrying 3,857 passengers on day one of operation. By the time the project reaches completion, a projected 103 stations will be running, 52 of which will be underground. A loan from the Japan International Cooperation Agency will fund the majority of the $5.2 billion project and the Government of Bangladesh will fund the remainder of the costs.
Reducing Congestion and Pollution
Bangladesh continues to experience high levels of population growth annually, with a current 2023 population of about 170 million. According to the CIA World Fact Book, the population of the industrialized city of Dhaka has grown from about 21.7 million to an estimated 23.2 million in 2023.
Increasing job opportunities in Dhaka have been attracting an increasing number of people to Bangladesh’s metropolitan capital, contributing to congestion and overpopulation in the area. The metro rail line will help to reduce congestion and pollution and improve the city’s air quality, which is currently among the worst in the world. Although transport accounts for slightly less than 10% of Bangladesh’s greenhouse gas emissions, carbon emissions and traffic-related pollution are major concerns and the metro rail will curb this by allowing for more environmentally friendly travel.
The electricity-powered metro rail will also reduce both the likelihood of traffic accidents and travel costs, affording commuters an economical and efficient alternative to traveling by bus or car. According to a World Bank report, people lose around 3.2 working hours daily in Dhaka due to congestion and slow driving speeds. To help alleviate potential congestion around train stations, experts advise that a wider network of efficient public transport, including improved bus services, undergo development in tandem with the new rail line.
Impact on the Bangladesh Labor Market
The metro railway in Bangladesh will have several benefits for Bangladesh’s labor market, the first of which is increased labor mobility. Labor mobility refers to the level of ease with which workers can move between jobs (within an economy) or to different areas (into other economies) to get to work. The development of an efficient public transport system in Dhaka will increase the mobility of Bangladeshi workers, making a wider variety of jobs accessible to a larger number of people, especially those in remote, rural areas.
The construction of the rail line itself will likely create around 12,000 jobs for engineers in Bangladesh in addition to generating jobs for the staff who will operate and maintain the metro stations, trains and parking facilities. The construction will also benefit local businesses, such as the Bangladesh-based company McDonald Steel Building Products, which produced the roof trusses that builders are using for the train stations. The metro will benefit smaller businesses by providing a new market for the sale of goods and provisions in and around stations.
The first metro railway in Bangladesh will have several positive environmental, social and economic effects on the country, particularly in the city of Dhaka, where it will operate. By providing a more economical and efficient mode of transportation, the metro rail will help create a more productive and mobile workforce while improving workers’ quality of life. Travel will be more environmentally friendly, traffic congestion and pollution will reduce and newly-generated jobs will boost the national economy while reducing poverty rates. A symbol of the economic development that Bangladesh has seen in recent years, the metro rail will help to promote continued economic growth into the future.
– Sophie Sadera
Photo: Flickr
Strengthening the Rule of Law in the Philippines
Against this backdrop, there is a growing demand for justice and accountability in the country. Recent statistics on poverty have underscored the urgent need to address these issues and restore the rule of law in the Philippines. Estimates show that national poverty increased from 16.7% in 2018 to 18.1% in 2021.
By strengthening the rule of law, the Philippines can begin to restore its democracy and ensure that resources benefit all members of society. Rule of law is a crucial factor in determining a country’s economic and social well-being. The weakening of institutions can impede the development of a democratic society that promotes socialization and inclusivity. In turn, extractive institutions that do not adhere to the rule of law breed a culture of inequality and poverty.
The Current State of the Rule of Law
The Philippines is experiencing a decline in its Rule of Law Index score, as the World Justice Project reported. The score decreased by 2.9% from last year, ranking the Philippines 102nd out of 139 countries. Key metrics that make up the rule of law index, such as order and security, criminal justice and fundamental rights that citizens hold, have shown continued deterioration.
The Philippines is also increasingly corrupt, according to Transparency International’s Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI). The country ranks 116th out of 180 countries in 2022, up from 113th in 2020.
In 2019, reports indicated the loss of an estimated 700 billion pesos in the country due to corruption, leading to further deprivation among the poor. Instead of the funds going toward economic production or social welfare, aid and education, the money was lost to government corruption.
Duterte’s war on drugs is an example of the deterioration of the rule of law in the Philippines. Starting in 2016, Duterte’s violent anti-drug operations have been responsible for extrajudicial killings and other human rights violations. Recent estimates suggest that more than 36,000 deaths have occurred in the name of the drug war, with blatant disregard for the due process of law.
The COVID-19 pandemic worsened corruption in the Philippines in 2020. Several high-ranking officials were accused of siphoning off millions of pesos from the government’s pandemic response budget, leading to outrage and calls for accountability. Although the government did hold some officials accountable for their actions, corruption remains a pervasive issue in the country.
Poverty in the Philippines
The Philippines possesses abundant human and natural resources and had been experiencing continuous economic growth since 1985. However, despite this progress, the country has yet to fully achieve its economic potential.
In 2021, according to the Asian Development Bank, roughly 19.9 million individuals lived below the poverty threshold of about 12,030 pesos monthly for a household of five and the deteriorating rule of law in the Philippines plays a significant role in perpetuating this issue. The weak justice system also creates an environment where people are less likely to trust the government and the legal system.
The weak rule of law leads to a lack of accountability for those who commit crimes and abuse their power. This results in impunity for the wealthy and powerful, who can get away with illegal activities and corruption while the poor continue to suffer. This was evident in the war on drugs as wealthy targets who could pay off vigilantes were less likely to be targeted in the first place.
The COVID-19 pandemic further worsened poverty in the Philippines, with Filipinos being even poorer today than in 2018. A staggering report by private polling firm Social Weather Station revealed that approximately 48% of the population considered themselves poor in 2022.
A Path Forward
New President Marcos Jr. has taken a strong stance against poverty, stating that he will strive to end his six-year term with a “single-digit” poverty rate. Although this goal could be difficult to achieve, it highlights the pressing nature of poverty within the country.
Despite the challenges, there are signs of progress. The Philippines government is making efforts to address the erosion of the rule of law, including investigating and monitoring human rights within the country, beginning with prosecuting corrupt politicians.
In 2019, the country passed a law to modernize and improve its court system. It also made efforts to increase transparency and accountability in government, such as establishing a Freedom of Information Order in 2016. This law gives citizens the right to access information that the government holds, with certain exceptions for national security and other sensitive matters. However, more and urgent action is necessary to protect the media, prevent extrajudicial killings and provide stronger social safety nets for the poor.
If the legal system can function effectively fairly, and impartially, it can provide the foundation needed for a government to flourish and encourage economic growth and poverty reduction. Conversely, the erosion of the rule of law can have devastating consequences for the poorest and most vulnerable members of society. Therefore, it is essential that the Philippines continue to work toward strengthening its legal system and ensuring that it can function independently and impartially, for the benefit of all its citizens.
– Andrew Giganti
Photo: Flickr